Feb 4, 2026 Not evaluated

Erdős problem #1150: claimed solution found in the literature, likely incorrect according to the wiki (Gemini Deep Research)

The gist

According to the teorth/erdosproblems wiki, Gemini Deep Research reportedly found in the literature a claimed solution to problem #1150, which the wiki considers likely incorrect (announced February 4, 2026).

DiscoverIA status on October 12, 2026: not evaluated, meaning no third-party evaluation found.

Status detailsDetails

AI draft, not reviewedWhat has not been reviewed?

Text written by an AI (DiscoverIA pipeline), on Oct 17, 2026. The status and its sources come from the registry; only the explanatory text has not been reviewed. A reported error is corrected, then the text is reviewed.

Follow Report

Cite this entry

A single status snapshot since Oct 12, 2026: a citation always points to a dated snapshot.

Cite snapshot 1, Oct 12, 2026

APA citation with the dated link

DiscoverIA. (2026, October 12). Erdős problem #1150: claimed solution found in the literature, likely incorrect according to the wiki (Gemini Deep Research) [Status: Not evaluated, snapshot 1]. DiscoverIA registry. https://discoveria.ai/entry/erdos-1150-gemini-deep-research-2a#releve-1

BibTeX @misc, key discoveria-erdos-1150-gemini-deep-research-2a-r1

@misc{discoveria-erdos-1150-gemini-deep-research-2a-r1,
  author       = {{DiscoverIA}},
  title        = {Erdős problem #1150: claimed solution found in the literature, likely incorrect according to the wiki (Gemini Deep Research)},
  howpublished = {DiscoverIA registry, entry erdos-1150-gemini-deep-research-2a},
  note         = {Status “Not evaluated”, snapshot 1, recorded on October 12, 2026. Literature search},
  year         = {2026},
  url          = {https://discoveria.ai/entry/erdos-1150-gemini-deep-research-2a#releve-1},
  urldate      = {2026-10-12}
}

Dated link opens this snapshot in the history

https://discoveria.ai/entry/erdos-1150-gemini-deep-research-2a#releve-1

To understand ≈ 20 s reading time, estimated

What it changes

Problem #1150 belongs to analysis (the study of functions and limits), around polynomials (sums of terms, each a coefficient multiplied by a non-negative integer power of a variable). It is listed as open on erdosproblems.com on October 12, 2026; if the claimed solution held, it would settle it.

What remains unclear

Only the wiki is cited for the reservation “likely incorrect”: the sources read say neither where the solution was found nor what the doubt rests on. A verification published after the wiki's freeze would not appear there.

For experts

Sources, method, key facts, status history, report an error

Status

Not evaluated

Recorded on Oct 12, 2026 · github.com · wiki

Step 1 of 4 on the scale: not evaluated. Next step: under review.

Feb 4, 2026Announced
Jun 30, 2026Wiki frozen
Oct 12, 2026Recordednot evaluated
nextTo follow

What this status means

Source reading : Source read word for word (level 3 of 3)

The result is declared neither right nor wrong.

To move to “Under review”: a public review under way. To “Peer reviewed”: a journal publication or a review by named experts.

Dated archive: status recorded on the wiki frozen on Jun 30, 2026

Full history

Sources

Main sourcegithub.com · wikipage read word for word · consulted on Oct 12, 2026
Reference listerdosproblems.comlink only, reading not recorded
Corroborationterrytao.wordpress.compage read word for word · consulted on Oct 17, 2026 · We have created a github repository to coordinate this process
Repositorygithub.com · CONTRIBUTING.mdpage read word for word · consulted on Oct 17, 2026 · this status is an unofficial crowdsourced classification of the problem

Method

Source: the “AI contributions to Erdős problems” wiki of the teorth/erdosproblems repository (a repository presented by Terence Tao in his blog post of August 31, 2025); frozen on June 30, 2026 (commit c8ad430, “freeze”) and read on October 12, 2026 in the git repository. Category 2(a), “Literature search” (secondary contribution). Humans named by the wiki: none; AI system: Gemini Deep Research. Date given by the wiki: February 4, 2026. Exact text: “Claimed solution found (likely incorrect)”; yellow flag (“partial progress”, according to the wiki's legend). Literature cited by the wiki: none. Status of the problem in the teorth/erdosproblems community database (data/problems.yaml, unofficial classification, snapshot of October 12, 2026 with no commit identified, current state, not that of June 2026): open (informal_status=open); no formalised solution known (formal_status=unformalized). This status concerns the problem, not this contribution. Problem page not read by DiscoverIA: https://www.erdosproblems.com/1150. DiscoverIA status: not evaluated (only the wiki's classification exists). Recorded on October 12, 2026.

Limits

DiscoverIA has not checked this contribution itself.

Key facts

Claimed by: Gemini Deep Research, according to the AI-Erdős wiki
announced on Feb 4, 2026
Nature: literature search
Field: Mathematics (Erdős problem #1150 (analysis ; polynomials))
Wiki category: Literature search (contribution secondaire : recherche bibliographique)
Wiki verdict: « Claimed solution found (likely incorrect) » : 🟡 progrès partiel (légende du wiki)
Checked by: no verifier identified
Sources: 4 : 3 read word for word, 1 link only
Part of: AI contributions to Erdős problems (wiki by T. Tao, frozen on June 30, 2026)
This entry: AI draft, not reviewed

Status history

Only one observation so far.

01Oct 12, 2026
First observation:Not evaluatedCurrent status
Source: github.comread word for word

An observation is added; none is ever erased.

In the same set

AI contributions to Erdős problems (wiki by T. Tao, frozen on June 30, 2026) · entry 495 of 521, by problem number

See all 521 entries

Report an error or suggest a source

Is your result listed?What each status requires, correcting this entry, replying to it.